Modern-Day Pinocchio: Exploring our own humanity

by Valerie M

http://images.businessweek.com/ss/07/08/0809_movie_robots/image/data2.jpg

“If being human is not simply a matter of being born flesh and blood – if it is instead a way of thinking, acting, and feeling – then I am hopeful that one day I will discover my own humanity. Until then … I will continue learning, changing, growing, and trying to become more than what I am.”

– Data in Data’s Day, Star Trek: The Next Generation

As is obvious by now, I am a huge Star Trek fan – closely bordering on obsession, really. I just don’t feel the need to watch anything else. For me, Star Trek does to television what Shakespeare does for literature. It attempts to explore humanity and human behavior and does so through elegant screenwriting and the skills of its actors.

To demonstrate, there have been quite a few episodes that have literally moved me to tears and have kept me up half the night. Other episodes, I don’t know whether to laugh or cry. If I haven’t hammered the last nail on my sanity’s coffin by now, I’m sure this will do it. But I just don’t care – it’s that good to me.

It’s pronounced ‘Day-ta,’ not ‘Dah-ta’…

One of my favorite characters in Star Trek is Data, the world’s only fully functional android (aside from his ‘brother,’ who is a rogue). Now, to me this isn’t shocking because I tend to like shows and movies that center on androids and robots. I-Robot, Bicentennial Man, Artificial Intelligence, Wall-E, you name it – I’m a sucker for it.

Now Data’s biggest dream is to be human. While he can walk, talk, and generally act human, his designer didn’t give him the ability to experience emotions. Nonetheless, he’s constantly on a quest to discover human emotions, relationships, and other nuances that are uniquely human. He has this great sense of wonder and a never-ending curiosity that drives people crazy at times and gets him into silly situations, but makes him all the more loveable.

And despite all of his strengths as an android and his ability to be logical, not having emotions that cloud his judgment, he’d give it all up to be human. This is in spite of other’s reassurances that he is indeed sentient and has every right to be there as everyone else.

There was even an episode where Captain Picard took another scientist to court and fought for Data’s rights as a sentient being – another episode that also leaves me bawling every time. In another episode, Data desired to procreate so he created his own offspring, a daughter named Lal, who unfortunately failed (died) shortly after. Yep – more tears.

By the way, I swear I normally don’t cry that much. It’s just that Star Trek seems to have this extraordinary grip and control of my tear ducts.

Pinocchio, Reincarnated

In a sense, Data is like a modern-day Pinocchio. Instead of wood, he’s made of a bunch of circuits and heavy metals. Instead of strings, he’s limited to what his positronic, computer brain can do.

As is shown in the quote at the beginning of this post, Data strives to grow and overcome his limitations. But ironically, in his effort to do so, Data actually becomes human. In his quest to become “more than he is,” by his own admission, there is the makings of emotion – desire, faith, sadness, happiness, disappointment.

It makes me think, isn’t that what being human is? Isn’t that what sets us apart from other species?

Anything can learn how to walk upright. Anything can have an instinct and blindly follow it. Anything can breathe and circulate nutrients around. Anything can have a “brain” in the loosest sense of the word. For what is a brain, except a network of [insert any word here] firing “messages” at each other?

Redefining humanity … or maybe that’s what it was all along

Being human isn’t about having your skin look a certain way and what your bones are made of. It’s about moving beyond our base behavior and exploring altered states of mind. It’s about having the ability to creatively push ourselves beyond our perceived capabilities. It’s about learning to adapt to our environment and then adapting our environment to suit us.

And that’s what we do. We’re just like Pinocchio. Just like Data. Not better than him. Not less than him. Just like him we don’t understand emotions – no matter how hard we try to break them apart and rationalize it with logic. And yet, we’re still entirely fueled by them.

Every day we strive to be better than what we are. Sometimes we fall far short of our expectations. A lot of times it doesn’t turn out the way we’d like. Often we’re temporarily set back and other times we want to give up completely (and do). And all too frequently we leave even more confused than ever. Just like Data.

At the end of the day, that’s what matters – that’s what makes us ‘human.’ That we dreamed. That we showed up. That we gave it our all.

Does it make him any less human than us? Does it make us any less ‘android’ than him? What’s the difference?

Does it matter?

Readers: Thoughts? Ideas? Random spurts of creativity? :) Share!

**If you’re new here and enjoyed this post, be sure to subscribe for future posts and updates. And feel free to share this post … I’d really appreciate it! Don’t forget to introduce yourself in the comments. Don’t be shy … I don’t bite. :) You can also add me on Twitter (@valeriemondesir).**

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitthis
  • Print

Related posts:

  1. Happiness and linear thinking is a difficult combination
  2. A Case Study: Dealing with seasonal mood swings
  3. I'm almost as cranky as Worf today.
  4. Get rid of dead weight: Channel frustration into creative ideas into action
  5. How to start exercising for wussies (and why you shouldn’t bother setting weight goals)

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

chris April 12, 2010 at 3:41 pm

Interesting article – you may have just convinced me to watch some episodes of star trek! You are right I wouldn’t say there was much difference – most people have the urge to transcend themselves to discover greater heights and explore their inner depths. Life is like that. What makes it complicated is that we are attempting to go beyond ourselves but what has to be considered deeply is why ?

Is it for positive reasons? Or negative?

Do we feel inadequate or are we trying to feel superior ?

Then we have outer circumstances that influence us!

Do they make us or break us? We are driven by our perceptions of the environment and many of these perceptions are a result of the scientific and religion information we’ve all to some degree imbibed.

At times its difficult to know what the truth is and with all the information that is available to us we can easily get overwhelmed and feel lost. Life can be manic at times and dealing with the psychological and emotional factors of growth arent easy. At times I feel that though everything is changing the part of me that is aware doesn’t. I think thebest to grow is to let your emotions guide you to the placeof joy and love and to constantly replace all negative thoughts with supporting ones. In many ways the only way to grow is to become more aware of who you are whatsrives your behaviour and hopefully in the process find new ways of perceiving and behaving which create an enjoyable experience of life that allows your essential humanity to express itself – the best version of yourself so to speak! If you have anything to say about what I’ve said which I admit ismore than I thought I would please do. I also write articles on my own blog so if you wanna have a look please do- I give you link later. Thanks again for your original article!

Jarrod@ Optimistic Journey April 12, 2010 at 9:23 pm

Along the journey of life we often lose sight of what it truly means to be human. Yes there are emotions involved, yes there are experiences and life lessons involved. Everything isn’t about facts, knowledge, numbers and computers.

Thanks, Val, for going beyond the realm to remind us all of this. Great post and thanks for sharing!!

Your friend,

Jarrod
Jarrod@ Optimistic Journey´s last blog ..You Know You’re Favored by God When… My ComLuv Profile

Valerie M April 12, 2010 at 9:58 pm

Hi Chris. Interesting comment, I thought a lot about it, but I’m still not quite sure how to answer. I’ll try my best to articulate my interpretation. I personally think it is human nature to want to improve. It’s innate drive that we can’t explain. In my humble opinion, there are two ways to express that drive: consciously and unconsciously. Unconscious people use external circumstances (e.g. to feel superior to someone else) as a reason for this innate drive for improvement, it seems. I personally believe that this drive is there to overcome basic human drives and to see beyond ourselves and our perceptions. An internal, spiritual challenge, so to speak. Well not overcome them, but to see them as they are and use them to our advantage … rather than blindly and unconsciously follow them. This may manifest itself in different ways, but the point is the same. I do agree with you that emotions are the key here. They tell us what we need to know, but they can get dangerous if we let them run us by not being conscious about them and reacting to them any which way.

I once read a quote: “We are spiritual beings having a human experience – not human beings having a spiritual experience.” I think it sums up what I’m trying to say and how I view this. For me it’s about experiencing and enjoying my time here, experimenting and seeing how far I can go, without forgetting where I come from and getting lost in the emotions and all the information you speak of. Obviously, I don’t know if this is the “correct” answer… if there is one… but this is what works for me lately. Not sure if I’m making sense or if I addressed your comment, but that’s the thoughts I got from reading it. Thanks for dropping by though, I really appreciate it. Be sure to share your link!

@ Jarrod: I agree 100% — it’s not about numbers and cold, hard facts. I often question… do the facts (or the statistics) come first or do we put them there? I feel like too many of us let the statistics dictate where we’re supposed to be going… then it’s just becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. It doesn’t have to be that way, though.

Jeremy Johnson April 14, 2010 at 1:42 pm

LOVE the data reference. I think I agree with the notion that we let statistics or ‘facts’ dictate where we are supposed to be going and as such, we become puppies on leashes. I think a better approach is to move toward what drives us and what we know add values independent of statistics.

Of course, when you then have that and you are looking to market it and ‘sell’ it to other people, statistics come in handy in knowing the response to what you’ve produced.
Jeremy Johnson´s last blog ..Approach Motivation and Avoidance Motivation My ComLuv Profile

Valerie M April 15, 2010 at 3:48 pm

@ Jeremy: I knew you’d approve! And yes, I agree with you that whatever we do is independent of statistics. There’s no doubt that statistics is helpful, it’s just that we give it so much power. In the end it will never completely replace good old common sense and your trusty gut on what works and what doesn’t.

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv Enabled

Previous post:

Next post: